Today I am drinking Long Jing (Dragonwell) green tea from two different vendors. I have Teavivre’s “Organic Superfine
” Long Jing and Life in Teacup’s
“Da Fo” Long Jing. I’ll go ahead and say from the start that these two Long Jings are not in the same price tier which should be considered if comparing them. The Teavivre Oraganic Superfine version is $13.90/50g and the Life in Teacup Da Fo is $22/50g. Teavivre does offer several other versions at various price points, including one called “Organic Nonpareil Ming Qian” which is $21.90/50g which might be a better comparison since it was harvested in late March like the Da Fo. Teavivre’s highest priced Long Jing is their “Organic Nonpareil She Qian” which is $34/50g. Likewise, Life in Teacup has a premium version called “Shi Feng” priced at $56/50g.
Here are these two teas at a glance:
|Teavivre||Life in Teacup|
|Name||Organic Superfine||Da Fo|
|Location||Zhejiang Province, Hangzhou prefecture, Lin'an County (Tianmu Mountain)||Zhejiang Province, Shaoxing prefecture, Xinchang County|
|Leaf Cultivar||Jiu Keng||Long Jing #43|
|Harvest Date||April 10, 2016||March 17, 2016|
|Price per 50g||$13.90||$22|
A look at the dry leaf shows that the Life in Teacup Da Fo Long Jing leaves have a more uniform and smaller appearance than the Organic Superfine Long Jing. The Organic Superfine leaf is a darker green. Both teas have a good amount of "fuzz" which is common with younger buds and early harvests. The aroma of the leaves is slightly different. Organic Superfine is nuttier than the Da Fo leaves which have a lighter and slightly floral aroma.
|Teavivre 2016 Organic Superfine Long Jing (left) and Life in Teacup 2016 Da Fo Long Jing (right)|
|An abundance of green tea fuzz balls in the Teavivre 2016 Organic Superfine Long Jing package. Post edit: More about these can be found here: Tea Trekker: What Is Tea Leaf Fuzz?|
After hydrating the leaves with the first infusion, the wet leaf aroma is quite different between the two. The Organic Superfine from Teavivre has a umami seawater aroma, and the Life in Teacup Da Fo has a distinct asparagus with black pepper aroma. The liquor of the Da Fo is slightly lighter in color, but both are very pale yellow.
|Teavivre 2016 Organic Superfine Long Jing (top) and Life in Teacup 2016 Da Fo Long Jing (bottom)|
The flavor of these two Long Jing teas is pretty different. The Teavivre Superfine Organic starts out nutty with a good dose of umami and a nice perfumy aftertaste. It is a very strong flavor despite such a light looking liquor. By the third infusion I noticed some grassy notes as well.
The Life in Teacup Da Fo flavor was much lighter, slightly buttery, and had a hint of a green bean taste. Throughout the infusions I noticed a very interesting peppery flavor. Umami is present, but balanced with some floral notes and a good sweetness at first which gives way to stronger umami in the later (fourth) infusion.
Back-to-back, the Da Fo is a much lighter delicate flavor than then Organic Superfine and seems more balanced. The Organic Superfine seemed easy to get bitter when pushed, but the Da Fo never got bitter, only trading sweetness for more umami flavor. Where the Organic Superfine had a nice nutty flavor note, the Da Fo had an unusual black pepper flavor note which was actually more pleasant than it might sound.
The hydrated leaves again show more variance in the Organic Superfine leaf shape/size where as the Da Fo has smaller leaves that are more uniform. A lot of this difference is due to both the cultivar difference and also the earlier harvest time of the Da Fo. These difference are also likely responsible for differences in the flavor.
|Teavivre 2016 Organic Superfine Long Jing|
|Life in Teacup 2016 Da Fo Long Jing|
Both of these teas work well brewed straight in a glass "grandpa" style. Due to the strength of the Organic Superfine, it's better to error on the side of less leaf than too much or expect the first few sips to possibly be bitter. The later additions of water will show a nicer balance and the strength of these leaves help it last a long time when brewed this way. Interestingly this method did not give me the umami flavors as much, but the nutty flavors were still there. I actually bought the Teavivre Organic Superfine Long Jing for the purpose of drinking this way.
|Teavivre 2016 Organic Superfine Long Jing|
It is not my goal to say that one of these is better than the other. I find that each one has strengths and weakness, and I would be in the mood for each one at different times. The Da Fo is a much more delicate brew that can be appreciated more in a more focused session, and the Organic Superfine was capable of producing a nice bold full flavored green tea experience.
Link to Teavivre Organic Superfine Long Jing: http://www.teavivre.com/organic-long-jing-green-tea/
Link to Life in Teacup: http://www.lifeinteacup.com/
I like your comparative style. (I found your blog via Tea For Me, Please.)ReplyDelete
Side-by-side comparison sessions are definitely my favorite and I feel like I can pick up on/learn more about each tea this way. They take longer though so I usually do them when I know I'll have a good solid block of time. Thank you for stopping by!Delete